The Van Trump Report

Cheaper Diesel Doesn’t Necessarily Mean Cheaper Freight

One of the more interesting developments in the transportation industry is that trucking rates are rising even as diesel prices have been retreating. For businesses accustomed to viewing fuel as the primary driver of transportation expenses, the divergence raises a bigger question about what actually determines the cost of moving goods across America.
According to FreightWaves, national dry-van spot trucking rates increased more than +4% from late October into mid-November, reaching their highest level since July, even as diesel prices declined approximately -3.5% over the same period. DAT Freight & Analytics reported that average dry-van spot rates reached $3.05 per mile in October, their highest monthly level since February 2022. Refrigerated trucking rates averaged $3.60 per mile, up +$1.12 from a year earlier. These are all-in spot-market rates, which include fuel.
The divergence suggests transportation costs are increasingly being influenced by something other than the price of diesel. Trucking companies have spent years dealing with expensive equipment, insurance, maintenance and financing while competing for freight in an unpredictable economy. Capacity has tightened, and shippers needing transportation on short notice are discovering that available trucks can command a premium.

Another factor is changing inventory management. Retailers and manufacturers have increasingly delayed replenishment to avoid the expense of carrying excess inventory. That improves cash flow while demand remains predictable, but it can create sudden competition for transportation when multiple businesses need shipments delivered within narrow windows. FreightWaves reported that October inventory growth reached its highest reading since 2022, contributing to unusual pressure on trucking rates ahead of the holiday shipping season.

There is an important financial trade-off here. Companies can save money by holding less inventory, but some of those savings may be surrendered through higher transportation rates when merchandise needs to move quickly. The cost hasn’t necessarily disappeared; it has shifted from warehouses and working capital to freight availability and delivery timing.
Meanwhile, the economics of moving goods by rail are becoming more attractive. FreightWaves reported that comparable intermodal movements offered approximately 30% savings relative to trucking in early November, with the cost advantage remaining above that level for five consecutive months. That doesn’t mean every shipment can move by rail. Transit requirements, terminal access, product handling and delivery distances can eliminate the advantage. But for businesses moving large volumes over established corridors, the savings could influence transportation contracts and future facility locations.
This matters to agriculture because transportation is part of the delivered cost of almost everything the industry produces or consumes. Fertilizer, feed ingredients, grain, meat and processed foods all depend on transportation networks. A producer’s competitiveness isn’t determined solely by production costs or the commodity price received. It also depends on what buyers must spend to move those products to their final destinations.
The pressure may not disappear simply because fuel becomes less expensive. The Energy Information Administration now forecasts diesel averaging $5.03 per gallon in 2027, down from $5.25 this year but substantially above its previous forecast of $4.49. Even if fuel costs moderate, transportation companies still must recover equipment, labor, insurance and other operating expenses, while available capacity and shipping urgency influence what customers ultimately pay.
The larger question is whether transportation access is becoming another competitive advantage for American businesses. A grain processor, food manufacturer or distribution center with reliable rail service and multiple shipping options may operate with greater flexibility than a competitor dependent on trucks alone.

For producers, the lesson is that cheaper fuel does not automatically produce better delivered prices or lower input costs. Transportation capacity, shipping flexibility and proximity to processing infrastructure can influence profitability independently of energy prices. In an increasingly competitive agricultural economy, the ability to move a product economically may become almost as important as the cost of producing it. (Source: Freightwaves.com, dat.com, eia.gov)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *